3415 forum posts
Ben Plewes wrote
You've hit the nail on the head Marc.
No pun intended??????? LOL
|1745 forum posts|
|Cheers guys. Baz, I couldn't resist that one!|
|7631 forum posts|
I always thought you did it the other way
No wonder there are bigger holes left after I've got the nail in and it takes flippin ages to do it!
|Olly Parry-Jones||21/06/2008 11:46:00|
2776 forum posts
Going back to the magazine then... One critisism I've seen elsewhere is of the amount of woodturning featured, particulalrly in this current issue. Clearly, some people don't notice the "& Woodturner" sub-title on the front cover!
I thought Alan Holtham's article was benefitial to all kinds of woodworkers, not only the 'turner. As for Ian Wilkie's light pulls, okay, so the more experienced wood turner would perhaps like to see something more challenging but it's a good way to use up offcuts and, from the beginner's perspective, they're fairly easy to turn and they'll give someone that all-important confidence and familiarity at the lathe to tackle something larger.
All magazines seem to get stick for featuring "simple" projects like this but I feel they are very important to getting people in to woodworking and helping them to progress. Even F&C is having to "dumb things down" a little under their new editor, so it seems.
Is Andy Standing registered on the forums or is he available to e-mail? I was interested to read his thought on the Charnwood planer-thicknesser as I have the identical machine from Axminster. I have found one major fault with the design of this machine but I'm not clear on what he meant by "the occasional wobbly knob"? I'd be interested to hear more from him.
I like the fact that you keep your reviews brief as I'm sure there are plenty of readers who are only looking for a score out of five and the pro's and con's at the end. On the other hand, I really like Andy King's reviews in Good Wood and the extent and depth to which he explores and tests many machines and tools...
All magazines have one problem though and it's something that can't be helped - you only get a couple of hours to 'play' with new products and so aren't going to be aware any long-term problems, especially with cheaper machines (belts slipping, chains wearing, adjustments moving, etc.) That's where I find the internet, and forums like this, invaluable so you can get a second opinion from someone who's been using a certain piece of kit for a substantial amount of time.
I haven't read through the Bosch and Festool articles yet but I like the look of the magazine overall. I used to avoid after Magicalia bought both mags. as I didn't think you'd be able to keep it so different to reading Good Wood - but you do a very good job and I'm happy subscribing to both publications.
Ben, and anyone else reading this, I hope you find some of it useful.
|Denis Solomon||25/06/2008 23:03:00|
|11 forum posts|
I was disappointed by your opening aricles in the Hand vs. Machine series in the July 2008 Woodworker. The first article, as was to be expected, contained material on mortise and tenon joint cutting that exists in many magazine articles and woodworking manuals. Fair enough. But I thought the second would be a compendium of techniques for cutting mortise and tenon joints with different machines, most or all of which the average woodworker would possess - bandsaw, table saw (with or without jigs), router and router table, mortiser attachment on planer or radial arm saw, etc., etc. - information that rarely if ever appears in a single article. Instead I found a description of the Trend mortise and tenon jig. Any reader who doesn't have this jig will be none the wiser for this article, and anybody who has one presumably already knows how to use it. The article was not about cutting joints by machine - it was about cutting joints on A machine.
|warren gruhl||26/06/2008 03:02:00|
536 forum posts
|Denis Solomon||27/06/2008 08:27:00|
|11 forum posts||I'm new to the forum, but I don't understand what Warren's post has to do with mine.|
|Mike Garnham||27/06/2008 08:31:00|
|4114 forum posts|
I think Warren has posted in the wrong place.
Please login to post a reply.
Want the latest issue of The Woodworker incorporating Good Woodworking? Use our magazine locator links to find your nearest stockist!
We're always happy to hear from you, so feel free to get in touch!