|David Allebone||02/10/2007 23:06:00|
|50 forum posts|
I read Steve's post about creative woodturning software, sorry Steve can't help but in your right up you said about copying others work. That got me thinking, If an item anyone wishes to copy or make their version of & said item had a copyright against it, then same said item turned up in a book or mag with a 'HOW TOO' article does that copyright still stand ?
|Bob Chapman||05/10/2007 21:59:00|
47 forum posts
It's an interesting question. Are actual turnings copyrighted to the people who turned them? I don't know, but your question made me think about paintings. I often see people, who I take to be artists, sitting in art galleries making sketches etc from the paintings hanging there. Are they infringing copyright because they are making copies?
Of course, the copies won't be identical to the originals (if they are, I believe its called 'forgery', and is frowned upon), and this applies to woodturning even more so, since no two pieces of timber will ever be identical even if the shape were accurately reproduced.
Is it the design which is copyright, rather than the actual finished turning? If so, presumably the copy would have to imitate the shape exactly before copyright was infringed? As an author of 'how to' articles myself, I consider that publishing an article (usually complete with photographs) showing how to make a particular item is tantamount to agreeing that anybody else can feel free to make a copy, i.e. copyright has been waived. If not, what would be the purpose or usefulness of such an article?
Is there a woodturning lawyer out there who could give us some definitive answers?
|Mike Riley||06/10/2007 21:59:00|
|337 forum posts|
F&C magazine often publish plans and "how tos" The plans however are clearly marked copyright and state that plans are for the private use only and that items built using the plans must not be for resale.
|Big Al||07/10/2007 09:53:00|
|1602 forum posts|
|I cant see how a copyright on a piece of woodwork can legally work. With regards to copyrights associated with plans, wether they are given away or purchased, then surely the copyright relates to the plans, not to the finished piece. At the end of the day I am sure most woodworkers would make changes to any piece that they make as a moulding or a dimension may not fit in with the individuals requirements. And also if someone either copied, or was inspired by one of my pieces, it would give me great satisfaction to know that.|
|Mike Riley||07/10/2007 11:31:00|
|337 forum posts|
Lots more info on the hows and whys of design copyright here.
Please login to post a reply.
Want the latest issue of The Woodworker & Good Woodworking? Use our magazine locator links to find your nearest stockist!
We're always happy to hear from you, so feel free to get in touch!