A tale of three smoothers

Robin Gates tunes three classic smoothing planes and is surprised by his results

 

 

I was sheltering from the rain in a local junk shop – or antiques store, as they call them nowadays. It can be a rueful experience browsing in these places, being reacquainted with the clutter I’ve thrown out, now waxed with a coat of dealer’s hyperbole and tied with a breath-taking price tag. But on this occasion I was pleasantly surprised by a wooden smoothing plane keeping company with the domestic bygones and, at £6, cheaper than fish and chips. At this price it stood in danger of being upcycled as a table lamp, so, as a woodworker, I felt duty-bound to return it safely to the bench.

Besides, although I already had a forest of woodies in the shed, ranging from jack and jointer to bullnose, plough and moulding planes, somehow the coffin smoother (so called because of its shape) had escaped me. I carried it to the cash desk as though it were an injured bird.

Together with my go-to Stanley No.4, and a Spiers infill plane I’d bought out of pure lust, the woody completed a trio of smoothing classics. While they all did the same job, they were as different from each other as Pavarotti, Domingo and Carreras, so I decided it would be illuminating to tune them equally and see how they performed when on song...

Read the full article in The Woodworker July 2017

For more great articles subscribe to The Woodworker today